Doorbird Intercom Alternative – BAS-IP. Who Suits You Better?
What is Doorbird
Doorbird is a German company that has been manufacturing IP intercoms since 2010 (however, the first model appeared in 2015). Doorbird is focusing on intercom mobile applications. The company just recently made its first intercom monitor.
The main office of the company is located in Berlin, Germany. Following the German tradition, most panels are made of stainless steel. Some Door bird panels like D2101 or D2102 are completely similar to another German brand – Siedle.
Doorbird has made integrations with many companies such as Control4, Crestron, KNX, and more. The company did not forget about the open API either. You can find the API on the official website of the company.
Doorbird Doorbell and Entry panels
The company’s clients are private houses and large apartment complexes with gated communities. For individuals, the company offers the replacement of the existing doorbell with a small intercom Doorbird panel with a call function on the mobile APP. And for large complexes – an intercom system based on IP.
Doorbird D101S
The Doorbird D101S is an innovative IP video door station that combines convenience, security, and design. This model comes in a Strato-Silver Edition with a robust polycarbonate housing and a stainless-steel faceplate. It’s compact in size, measuring 157 x 75 x 35 mm (H x W x D), which translates to 6.18 x 2.95 x 1.38 in (H x W x D).
This door station can be powered by either a 15 V DC power supply (with voltage ranging from 110 to 240 V AC) or Power over Ethernet (PoE 802.3af Mode-A), offering flexibility in installation. It comes with connectors for power, an electric door opener/strike, a door chime, a door opener button, and the network.
The Doorbird D101S is equipped with an HDTV 720p dynamic camera, ranging from VGA to HDTV, ensuring clear and sharp images. For nighttime visibility, it has a light sensor, an automatic IR-cut filter, and 12 IR-LEDs for night vision. It also features integrated Wi-Fi with a 2.4 GHz external antenna, which provides a strong and reliable wireless connection.
In the package, you’ll find the video door station, a mounting plate, a DIN-rail, and a screw package for easy installation. Please note that the power supply is sold separately. The Quickstart Guide included will walk you through the setup process, making it easy even for beginners.
Doorbird Indoor Stations
When comparing indoor station options, two significant players emerge in the field: DoorBird and BAS-IP. Both offer impressive features that cater to different needs and preferences, making them strong competitors.
DoorBird offers a single model of indoor station, the DoorBird A1101. This model comes with a 4-inch True Color Touch Display and is available in both black and white color options. It is characterized by its intuitive user interface, SIP support for additional connectivity, and features such as door opener and elevator control, visitor history recording, and room-to-room communication when multiple units are installed. It also offers weather forecast display and a configurable RGB LED status bar. For those who value simplicity and consistency across their system, DoorBird’s single model approach might be appealing.
On the other hand, BAS-IP provides a more diverse range of options with seven different indoor station models. These models come in 4, 7, and 10-inch high-resolution display sizes, providing more choices to match the size and design of your interior spaces. In addition to black and white, BAS-IP also offers a gold color option, giving an extra touch of luxury. It’s worth noting that the larger display sizes and color options might appeal to those looking for more customization and variety.
Video Door Phones
In terms of features, both DoorBird and BAS-IP offer comparable functionalities such as door control, visitor access features, and third-party integration capabilities. However, BAS-IP stands out with additional features such as face recognition, access control options like EM-Marin/Mifare/NFC/Bluetooth, and multi-factor authentication.
Doorbird A1101
The Doorbird A1101 Indoor Station is a versatile and sophisticated device that offers a plethora of features. This unit allows for door opener and elevator control, and it keeps a visitor history with free Cloud Recording, providing you with an added layer of security and convenience.
The A1101 Indoor Station promotes room-to-room communication when multiple units are in use, and with SIP support, you can easily reach out to a concierge or facility manager. It also displays weather forecasts, keeping you informed and prepared for the day ahead.
With the DoorBird App, you can configure the Indoor Station from anywhere in the world. The intuitive user interface, combined with a 4″ True Color Touch Display, ensures seamless navigation and a pleasing user experience. It also features five hardware buttons for main functions and a configurable RGB LED status bar that adds a touch of personalized color to your home.
The Doorbird A1101 supports WiFi, Ethernet, and Power over Ethernet (PoE), offering flexible connectivity options.
Doorbird vs Ring vs BAS-IP
| Feature | Doorbird D101S | Ring Doorbell Elite | BAS-IP AV-08FBL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Poe | Poe | Poe |
| Weather protection | Yes, IP65 | No info | Yes, IP65 |
| API | Yes | No | Yes |
| 3rd Party Integration | Yes | No | Yes |
| Face Recognition | No | No | Yes |
| Access Control | No | No | EM-Marin/Mifare/NFC/Bluetooth |
| Virtual keys (PIN codes) for visitor access | No | No | Yes |
| QR codes for visitor access | No | No | Yes |
| Keyless Entry | No | No | Yes |
| Multifactor Authentication | No | No | Yes |
| Number of Indoor Monitor Models | 1 | 1 | 7 |
| Indoor Monitors Installation | Wall mount, desktop | Desktop | Wall mount, desktop |
| Third-party Cameras Integration | Yes | No | Yes |
This chart should help you to compare the features of each doorbell system.
As for the multi unit intercoms, below you find a comparison chart of Doorbird and BAS-IP IP systems. We do think that BAS-IP is a better Doorbird alternative according to the features it gives for less money.
BAS-IP – Best Doorbird Alternative
*BAS-IP supports Mifare Classic, Plus, Desfire EV1, Ultralight.